Why David, Why Not Saul

by Timothy Howe

This week I want to look at something that frustrating me in times past. As many of you know, I like studying the Bible. I really enjoy learning about its history and background which serve to explain its teachings. Some of these teachings are not always super easy to decipher.


The events surrounding the lives of the first two kings of Israel is an area that once upon a time really bothered me. Many of you may know the story of these two men - Saul and David.


Saul a Man's Man
Saul was chosen by Samuel as directed by God. He was tall, good looking, and a fierce warrior. By all accounts he served as a faithful king with a few mess-ups along the way. He had a real temper and made a few inappropriate boasts, oaths and sacrifices. But we would almost expect these slight imperfections in our leaders.


David a Loyal Man
David followed Saul as king after Saul and his son Jonathan died in a terrible battle. This came on the heals of a strange and tortuous relationship between David, King Saul and Prince Jonathan. David had been in the court of Saul serving as both a warrior and a musician for the King. In addition, David was best friends with Prince Jonathan. David was grieved at his loss. At one point, Saul tried to destroyed David out of jealousy because David was becoming very popular in Israel, but David remain true to his King.


David a Failed Man
Eventually David replaced Saul and he then served as king. During his reign, David married several wives, something strictly forbidden by God; he had an improper relationship with another man's woman; he had that man killed; and he stirred up hatred between his own children that led to them killing each other. This sounds like really bad stuff. As bad as Hollywood could dream up.


Then why David over Saul?
Yet the Scriptures teach that God rejected Saul and took his throne away for sinfulness while it teaches that David was a man after God's own heart who would have someone sit on his throne forever. Indeed, the Messiah came from the lineage of David. What is up with that? Why was Saul rejected and David accepted as king?


This week I want to explore that question. Today, I want to focus on King Saul. What sin caused Saul to be rejected? You can find the answers in 1 Samuel beginning in chapter 9 or by clicking on this link - Saul Chosen to be King.


So, what is your first guess? What sin caused Saul to be rejected?

Get a free sms student response system at Poll Everywhere